Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
这坨东西基本算不上电影。要是叫《黑客帝国20周年重聚特别节目》我还能再给一星。真就一文不值，要啥没啥，全面不如99年。
一代神作重启首站拍成这样真是稀碎~
that's 狗屁，喷优。←阿祖早已看穿了一切…… 坦迪·牛顿和丽贝卡·弗格森，前后两任碟女郎同框 可还行。
对世界挽留的刻画有点真实，大概来自导演的嗑药体验。本来以为会对被极右搞臭了的概念做点更新，也没看到。
硬汉推理+纯爱故事本来是个很好的组合，可惜完成度都不算高，科幻设定也只是个没有骨肉的背景板。
草哈哈哈哈哈哈哈看采访才发现s8里狼的基友是种草莓的粒子
肯定没有前三部好，但是也没有说的那么差劲吧...有一些想象力爆棚的地方还是值得肯定的。
导演你怎么敢不停穿插老版的画面啊，现在的基努里维斯和年轻时的他对比惨烈的有点辛酸，和中年失业的直男炫耀自己大学拿校园辩论大赛冠军的辉煌旧照一样辛酸，文戏混乱我还可以归因自己的理解不行或者字幕问题，打戏露怯到这个地步连合格的爆米花都配不上，亚裔女主像袁咏仪
更像是炒冷饭的一部，如果已经忘了三部曲的内容直接看，感觉会很摸不着头脑。吐槽磨叽的太多，后续的故事和场景设计也没有给人惊艳，总有种似曾相识，后边的大场面还可以，特别是集体跳楼那里的场面很震撼。英雄迟暮啊，一个时代的经典过去了，再拍已然没有了当年的震撼感，毕竟这么多年过去了出现了那么多优秀的科幻电影，即使自己人再拍也难以撼动当年三部曲的地位，留下的只有回忆。
剧本很烂，故事混乱逻辑难自洽，台词幼稚让人尴尬，导演根本驾驭不了，只好故做深沉不断画外音，科幻的背景下，包装了一个烂熟的爱情故事。观众尚不明所以，导演却已沉迷其中，为所谓爱情感动得一塌糊涂。
hbo有粤语了，还好吧，符合期待的。前三部剧情忘得七七八八了，这部时不时回顾就让人想起来。前半部分剧情是简单明白的，后半段越来越复杂感觉就太过主角光环的不合理了，营救回女主角什么的太顺利了。
视觉上严重退步，尤其是打戏部分，真没想到沃卓斯基居然退步到这种程度，不求带来新元素，但连三部曲标志性的炫酷感，也没了，火车部分想起《釜山行》，人肉炮弹坠楼的设计，近有《速度与激情8》、远有沙马兰的《灭顶之灾》，想当年三部曲的“子弹时间”引领潮流，如今却在“拿来”别人的创意，没创意，还没诚意，还有那些泛滥成灾的升格镜头，看吐了。。。尼奥新学了一招发大波技能，先不说有多土，既然之前使用过两次，威力也不小，那最后大战怎么一次没见你用呢，至于尼奥怎么会这项技能的，没解释，就像崔妮蒂最后怎么就会飞了，也不解释。。。片中数次闪回三部曲的画面，而每次的闪回都在提醒我，和三部曲比起来，本片是有多么的差，我明白你们想卖情怀，但这次翻车翻了。。。。
云山雾罩的只有氛围感有啥用？好好弄剧本啊～都是白扯啊
我觉得打五星完全是对导演的侮辱和对电影公司资本的吹捧
【1】看第一幕的时候我在想：也太难看了吧，结果第二、三幕的难看程度又超出我预期。不是在讨论虚实了，更像以纯粹虚假的姿态展开粗暴思辨。但曾经已精准模拟当下，所谓的与时俱进恰恰是失败所在，我们不再需要一次折返，甚至抛舍掉可贵的意趣，或许Meta-Film已沦为过时概念？
然而诺兰弟妹指导的这部电影长片处女作格局还是小了，把重心放在了爱情上，悬疑和科幻全都像是为了“狼叔”谈恋爱而硬凑的，节奏缓慢、张力单薄。
这是找了多少超感8的演员，两姐妹夹带私货；吐槽华纳笑shi；小乔动作戏还可以；基努里维斯话都说不清楚了，就还是去隔壁突突突就好；和三部曲没有关系。
东京火车乘客秒变绿眼机器人。
看到了一个中文渗透英文的未来 (￣▽￣) （其实觉得还蛮自然的就默认听懂了）what is it with people finding the English accent attractive (￣▽￣) and why the Westworld flashbacks (￣▽￣) 还是较有效虽然鸡皮疙瘩地煽了一下的爱情故事
听到那个对法语骂人形容的时候我还是初中生 然后竟然还真学了法语 😂
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
